How to Analyze Competitor Reviews
min read - Updated on Nov 17, 2026You can analyze competitor reviews in Kimola by collecting the public reviews of your product and your rivals' products in one Report, comparing them side by side, reading which alternatives customers name and turning the gaps into an Action Plan. Kimola classifies every review into themes and sentiment and answers research Dimensions such as Pain Points and Substitutions, so you see what a rival's customers praise, what they complain about and in which themes each brand is stronger. This guide follows the four steps of the method: collect the reviews, compare the brands, read what customers compare you to and plan against a rival.
Reports from links, Compare, the Substitutions Dimension and the Action Plans of a Report are available in every package. Sign in to your Kimola account and have the review page links of your own product and of at least one rival's product ready, from platforms that Kimola supports.
The Goal
This guide answers the question product managers, marketers and founders ask before they decide what to build, fix or say next: where does our product stand against a rival in the eyes of customers. Customers write reviews without being asked, and the reviews of a rival's product are public, so you can study a rival without access to its data. The result is an evidence-based view of where customers prefer a rival, where they prefer you and which demand the rival leaves open.
A company sells a coffee maker and wants to know why shoppers choose a rival's model. It adds the review pages of its own model and of two rival models to one Report. The comparison might show that grinder noise is a large negative theme in a rival's reviews and a small one in its own, while cleaning effort is the opposite. The first is a point to claim in its messaging. The second is a problem to fix.
Step 1: Collect Reviews from Several Links
Create one Report from the review pages of your own product and your rivals' products, so that every brand is classified with the same models and answers the same Dimensions. On Home, click add multiple in the search bar of the report creation area. The Add Links window opens. Paste each link on a new line. Kimola checks the links and shows "The link is valid!" or "The link is invalid." for each one, and "All links are valid!" when every link passes. Remove or correct invalid links before you continue. The full method is in Create a Report by Adding Links.
[Screenshot: The Add Links window with the review page links of five products, one per line.]
Kimola reads the platforms it supports, and not every platform supports multi-link analysis. See Supported Platforms for Creating Reports from Links before you collect the links.
The next steps of the wizard set up the analysis. Move the slider to choose the report size, and confirm that you will use the extracted reviews for research purposes only. In the classifiers step, choose the Automatic Classifier, which discovers the themes of your data, and the Sentiment Classifier. In the Structure step, turn on Enable Multi-label Classification, so that a review that praises one aspect of a product and criticizes another receives a label for each. See Multi-label vs Single-label Classification.
In the Dimensions step, select three Dimensions from the list: Pain Points, which asks what goes wrong or creates difficulty, Unmet Needs, which asks what is missing or desired, and Substitutions, which asks "Instead of what does this occur?" It is listed under Comparisons, and Step 3 of this guide reads it. The Pain Points and Unmet Needs answers show what each brand's customers struggle with and wish for.
The Dimensions you select appear under My List on the left side, so you can review them before you create the Report.
Every Dimension you select adds to the queries of the Report: queries = rows × models × Dimensions. See How to Calculate Queries for an example.
On the Review screen, type a Report Title, because a Report with several sources has no single page title to take it from, for example "Coffee makers: our model and two rivals". Sources lists every link. Check Required Query, then click Create Report. When the Report is ready, click View Report.
[Screenshot: The Review screen of a multi-link Report with the title typed and the Sources listed]
Step 2 compares the brands by a column of the Report, so choose links that give you a column that tells the brands apart. Every Report from links has a Platform column. Some platforms add more: Trendyol and Hepsiburada add the seller name, and Belk, Costco, Kohl's and Macy's add the product name. The list is in Supported Platforms for Creating Reports from Links.
Compare works inside one Report. When the columns of a Report cannot tell your brands apart, create a Report from the links of the rival alone and write its Action Plan for the side A rival in Step 4.
Step 2: Compare Brands
Open the Report and click Compare in its menu. Compare sets parts of the Report's feedback side by side and shows the same analysis for each part, so you see at a glance what the customers of one brand talk about that the customers of another do not. It reads the analysis the Report already has, so it uses no queries. See Compare in Reports for every part of the page.
Click the column that tells your brands apart in the Compare by Columns bar, such as the product name, the seller name or the platform. A list of its values opens. Click your own brand first, because the first part stays on the left and the others follow it. Then click the rivals you want to compare. The button at the bottom shows how many parts you chose, such as Compare (3), and a comparison holds at most 5 parts. Click Compare.
[Screenshot: The Compare by Columns list with the product name column open and three values chosen]
Read the result from top to bottom, and read every row from left to right. Volume shows how many reviews each brand has and its share of the Report, which tells you how much weight to give each part. Sentiment shows the Positive, Negative and None reviews of each brand, each with its number and its share. Classifications lists the themes of each brand with their number of reviews, share and sentiment, so a theme that is mostly negative for one brand and mostly positive for another stands out. Dimensions lists the Pain Points, Unmet Needs and Substitutions answers of each brand. Popular Terms lists the words each brand's reviews use most often.
In a comparison of three coffee makers, the theme Water Reservoir is mostly positive for your model, marked "88% Positive", and mostly negative for the first rival, marked "76% Negative". In the Pain Points row of the first rival, the answer leaks after a month is among the largest. That gives you a point to check in your product messaging.
The most telling results are often the mismatches. The labels of an opened classifier follow your brand, the first part. When a rival's reviews have a theme that yours do not, Kimola lists it under Mismatches at the end of that rival's column, so you find the themes that exist only in one rival's feedback.
To see a rival's themes as the main list, start a new comparison and choose that rival first.
To keep a split of the reviews as a table, build it in Tables instead. Drag the brand column into the table, then a Dimension such as Pain Points, and Kimola shows the pain points of each brand with their shares. See Tables in Reports.
Step 3: See What Customers Compare You To
Open the Dimensions page of the Report and click the Substitutions tab. Substitutions asks every review "Instead of what does this occur?" and finds the alternatives that customers set a product against: a rival product, an earlier version, another brand in the category or a way of solving the problem by hand. Kimola groups the same alternative across all the reviews and counts the records behind each one. See What is the Substitutions Dimension? for how it reads feedback.
A ring at the top shows the share of the Report's records that answer the question, which tells you how comparative your feedback is. Reviews that name no alternative get no answer. The summary card says in a few paragraphs what customers compare the products with and which alternatives they leave for the reviewed products. Below it, each alternative is a cluster with its number of records, its share, a short summary and quotations in customers' own words. Cluster Scale shows an alternative's share of the records that answer Substitutions, and Dataset Scale shows its share of all the records in the Report.
[Screenshot: The Substitutions tab of a multi-link Report with its summary and its largest clusters]
To find out which brand's reviews an alternative comes from, click Columns on the cluster card and read the values of your brand column behind it. To read the answers of each brand next to each other, open Compare again and read the Substitutions row under Dimensions.
For the coffee maker Report, Substitutions might show three large clusters: a rival's model, a capsule machine and a manual pour-over setup. The Columns button on the a rival's model cluster shows that most of its records come from reviews of your model, so customers who own yours mention that rival. The a manual pour-over setup cluster shows that part of the competition is a habit, and no brand.
The alternatives are not always competitors. A habit, a workaround or an older product of yours can be what customers compare you with, and these answers tell you what you compete with. When you add the review pages of a rival's product to the Report, you can find your own product among the alternatives its customers name, together with the reasons they give.
One review can name more than one alternative, so the shares on Cluster Scale can add up to more than 100%.
To learn why customers choose one alternative over another, add the Motivations Dimension to the Report. On an analyzed Report, open the Dimensions page, click a tab without a check mark and click Generate Now. A Dimension added this way uses queries, as in Step 1. See Add Dimensions to a Report.
Step 4: Plan Against a Rival
Click Actions in the menu of the Report and click Create an action plan. An Action Plan turns the Report's feedback into up to 12 concrete actions, each tested against the evidence in the reviews. For competitor research, the plan can be written from your side or from the side of a rival, so the same feedback gives different actions. A complaint about your own product is something to fix, and the same complaint about a rival's product is demand you can win. See Create an Action Plan for every step of the wizard.
In the first step, choose the Profile the plan is written for, which is your company, or create one with a name and a short description of what it offers and to whom. The second step, Where do you stand?, shows Kimola's suggestion of the side. Check it, because the plan is written from it. Choose A rival to learn how to win the demand a rival leaves open, or Our own offering to learn what to fix, protect and build on. A Report can hold several plans, so you can write one for each side.
Under Choose column values naming you, pick the column that tells the brands apart, search the values with Search values and tick every spelling of the brand the plan is about. For the side Our own offering, tick your brand, and the other brands are compared with you as your rivals. For the side A rival, tick the rival.
[Screenshot: The Where do you stand? step with A rival selected, the product name column chosen and the rival's value ticked]
In the third step, choose the goal. Competitive strategy writes actions on where to attack rivals and where to defend. Balanced covers what matters most, of every kind, and is selected when the step opens. Under The situation, you can describe in your own words what you are facing. Leave it empty if you have nothing to add. Choose the language under Written in, then click Generate the Action Plan.
For the coffee maker Report, a company chooses the side A rival, ticks the first rival's model and the goal Competitive strategy. In the situation field, it writes "We launch a new model with a larger reservoir in spring and need to decide which claims to lead with."
Kimola forms hypotheses, reads the evidence, writes the actions and checks every claim. This takes about 5 to 7 minutes, and you can leave the page. When the plan is ready, each action card says what to change, for whom and when, who owns it, how confident Kimola is (High, Medium or Low) and How to See It Worked, with the evidence behind it. Actions the checks cannot support are dropped. Rate each action with Useful, Already known, Too vague, Wrong or Not for us, so your team sees which actions to follow. See Actions in Reports and Rate Actions in an Action Plan.
What You Get
The method gives you four results, each tied to the reviews behind it.
A multi-source Report. The reviews of your product and your rivals' products in one dataset, classified into themes and sentiment, with Pain Points, Unmet Needs and Substitutions answers for each brand.
A side-by-side comparison. For each brand, the volume of reviews, its sentiment, its themes, its Dimension answers and its popular terms, with the themes that only one brand has listed as mismatches.
A map of alternatives. The products, habits and workarounds customers name instead of yours, with the number of records behind each one and the quotations that show how customers put it.
An Action Plan for a rival. Up to 12 actions with an owner, a metric and a way to check that it worked, written for the side you chose.
Next Steps
Save the filters you use most, such as the 1-star reviews of one product, so you can return to the same comparison. See Save Filters in a Report. To share the findings with your team, export the Report as a PowerPoint file. To go deeper into one result, follow How to Find Customer Pain Points or How to Turn Customer Feedback into an Action Plan.
For more on analyzing product and shopper reviews with Kimola, see E-commerce feedback analysis.